| 11 Products | Sep 2025 | Sep 2026 | Change |
| Pilgrims Choice Mature Cheddar Cheese (350g) | £3.94 | £3.94 | £0.00 No change |
| | £3.08 | £3.08 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.20 | £4.20 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.20 | £4.20 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.19 | £4.19 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.50 | £4.50 | £0.00 No change |
| | £3.18 | £3.18 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.20 | £4.20 | £0.00 No change |
| Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese (350g) | £3.97 | £3.90 | - £0.07 -1.8% decrease |
| | £2.78 | £2.78 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.20 | £4.20 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.20 | £4.25 | + £0.05 0.3% increase |
| | £4.19 | £4.19 | £0.00 0.5% increase |
| | £4.50 | £4.50 | £0.00 0.3% increase |
| | £3.72 | £3.18 | - £0.54 -2% decrease |
| | £4.20 | £4.20 | £0.00 -1.8% increase |
| Pilgrims Choice Mature Cheddar Cheese (550g) | £5.05 | £5.22 | + £0.17 3.4% increase |
| | £3.98 | £5.20 | + £1.22 30.7% increase |
| | £5.40 | £5.20 | - £0.20 10.9% decrease |
| | £5.40 | £5.40 | £0.00 6.9% increase |
| | £5.19 | £5.19 | £0.00 5.2% increase |
| | £4.95 | £4.95 | £0.00 4.2% increase |
| | £5.40 | £5.40 | £0.00 3.4% increase |
| Pilgrims Choice Vintage Cheddar (300g) | £3.68 | £3.82 | + £0.14 3.8% increase |
| | £2.59 | £2.59 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.20 | £4.25 | + £0.05 0.6% increase |
| | £4.19 | £4.19 | £0.00 0.5% increase |
| | £3.72 | £4.25 | + £0.53 3.8% increase |
| Pilgrims Choice Lighter Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese (350g) | £3.67 | £3.38 | - £0.29 -7.9% decrease |
| | £2.78 | £2.78 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.20 | £4.25 | + £0.05 0.9% increase |
| | £4.19 | £3.00 | - £1.19 -10.2% decrease |
| | £3.50 | £3.50 | £0.00 -7.9% increase |
| Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese (550g) | £4.99 | £4.99 | £0.00 No change |
| | £3.98 | £3.98 | £0.00 No change |
| | £5.40 | £5.40 | £0.00 No change |
| | £5.40 | £5.40 | £0.00 No change |
| | £5.19 | £5.19 | £0.00 No change |
| Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Cheddar Sliced (150g) | £2.22 | £2.18 | - £0.04 -1.8% decrease |
| | £1.57 | £1.75 | + £0.18 11.5% increase |
| | £2.55 | £2.25 | - £0.30 -2.9% decrease |
| | £2.55 | £2.55 | £0.00 -1.8% increase |
| Pilgrims Choice Extra Mature Grated Cheddar (180g) | £2.62 | £2.52 | - £0.10 -3.8% decrease |
| | £2.55 | £2.25 | - £0.30 -11.8% decrease |
| | £2.55 | £2.55 | £0.00 -5.9% increase |
| | £2.75 | £2.75 | £0.00 -3.8% increase |
| Pilgrims Choice Lighter Mature Cheddar Cheese (350g) | £3.26 | £3.26 | £0.00 No change |
| | £2.59 | £2.59 | £0.00 No change |
| | £4.20 | £4.20 | £0.00 No change |
| | £3.00 | £3.00 | £0.00 No change |
| Pilgrims Choice Mature Sliced Cheddar (140g) | £2.25 | £2.25 | £0.00 No change |
| | £2.25 | £2.25 | £0.00 No change |
