Top 11 Extra Mature Cheddar Cheeses Products

Get ready for some seriously delicious cheese – discover the best Extra Mature Cheddars around, with reviews and handy tips on where to buy them.
1

What people say

84 reviews from 5 shops
“I love strong tasty cheese”
“This is a lovely full-flavoured cheese and at a very economical price”

Where to buy

£5.30
£5.50
£5.70
+2
STORES
2

What people say

118 reviews from 4 shops
“This is the tastiest extra mature that I have ever tried! For me it is perfect! So glad I tried it!! Highly recommended!”
“This is a great flavoured cheese”

Where to buy

£2.75
£3.55
£4.50
+1
STORE
3

What people say

12 reviews from 1 shop
“Love this lighter version”

Where to buy

£4.25
4

What people say

66 reviews from 8 shops
“i love this cheese it is great on its own but its even better in cheese dishes”
“Love the mature taste”

Where to buy

£3.00
£3.00
£3.00
+5
STORES
5

What people say

56 reviews from 5 shops
“I love it in a toastie with loads of sliced green finger chillies! It tastes better than a lot of "vintage" cheeses do! Getting through a block every week ½ now - oh yes!”
“Very mature tasty cheese that leaves NO bitter after taste behind”

Where to buy

£3.33
£4.75
£4.85
+2
STORES
6

What people say

56 reviews from 1 shop
“I think that it is about one of the best on the market and certainly has a better texture/flavour than Cathedral which I find greasy to cook with too”
“I love strong cheddar and this is the best I've tasted in a while”

Where to buy

£5.40
7

What people say

518 reviews from 1 shop

Where to buy

£4.98
8

What people say

164 reviews from 1 shop
“I love the taste of this cheese and when you get through as much as our household does (just 2 adults and a 3yo) you need more of a budget cheese! Always on offer too which is great”
“Love this cheese and its become a firm favourite at home especially now at its new lower price”

Where to buy

£3.35
9

What people say

49 reviews from 2 shops
“I love this cheese - strong tasting and very creamy”
“This is delightful”

Where to buy

£2.90
£3.65
10

What people say

104 reviews from 1 shop
“Very delicious and creamy”
“This is my cheddar of choice”

Where to buy

£3.35