Top 10 Mature Cheddar Cheese Products

Indulge in the rich taste of Mature Cheddar Cheese with our top products. Check out reviews and find where to buy them for a cheesy treat.
1

What people say

444 reviews from 6 shops
“I love extra mature cheddar so it would be great if it was available in other versions”
“This is truly a delicious cheddar whether you're interested in lacto free or not!! My husband needs lacto free products and we have been buying the mild (rubbery?) one for some time - I found it too bland personally”

Where to buy

£2.00
£2.25
£2.50
+3
STORES
2

What people say

507 reviews from 10 shops
“I love cathedral city cheese an this one didn’t disappoint very tasty an fresh lovely”
“The taste is wonderful I can add to dishes or have a sandwich it is very well priced for a big block great on baked potatoes”

Where to buy

£2.93
£3.00
£3.25
+7
STORES
3

What people say

498 reviews from 6 shops
“This is my usual cheese but I do try other cheeses but alway go back to this one for excellent flavour and as a mature cheese it has just about right”
“This is the nicest cheese in the world and I've tried a lot of cheeses!! The only downside for this amazing cheese is that it is a tad overpriced”

Where to buy

£4.40
£5.34
£5.35
+3
STORES
4

What people say

1,309 reviews from 1 shop
“This is great value and tastes as good as more expensive branded mature cheddar cheeses and it's now our preferred choice”
“This is a great cheese for the money strong and tasty and a lot less money than named Brand's l would recommend it every time”

Where to buy

£2.50
5

What people say

241 reviews from 4 shops
“These cheese is great it has a strong mature flavour still even though it is a lighter cheese”
“Love how it's a lighter version so you can feel like you're not eating as much fat as the normal version but yet it still tastes the same”

Where to buy

£5.34
£5.35
£5.40
+1
STORE
6

What people say

139 reviews from 1 shop
“This is excellent for melting and baking”
“Very creamy tasting cheese and not overly powerful”

Where to buy

£4.00
7

What people say

266 reviews from 6 shops
“This is my new favourite cheese love the tangy taste to it the whole family love it its great with a pasta bake and jacket potato well worth the money if you love strong tasting cheese this is the cheese for you”
“Very versatile product tasted great both cold on crackers as well as when fused in cooking”

Where to buy

£4.40
£5.34
£5.35
+3
STORES
8

What people say

287 reviews from 7 shops
“I love a good strong creamy cheese was definitely not disappointed in this it's perfect with anything pastas on toast with crackers was a massive hit a Christmas with caramalised onion chutney on crackers”
“I think that this Cathedral City Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese is probably the he nicest cheese around & there're loads of great cheeses about”

Where to buy

£2.93
£3.25
£3.25
+5
STORES
9

What people say

151 reviews from 5 shops
“I love it in a toastie with loads of sliced green finger chillies! It tastes better than a lot of "vintage" cheeses do! Getting through a block every week ½ now - oh yes!”
“Very mature tasty cheese that leaves NO bitter after taste behind”

Where to buy

£3.33
£4.75
£4.75
+2
STORES
10

What people say

587 reviews from 1 shop
“This is a flavoursome and tasty cheese with a great many uses”
“This is a lovely mature cheddar and a must buy every week”

Where to buy

£2.50