Top 8 Pilgrims Choice Products

Discover the UK's favourite pilgrims choice products, see how shoppers rate them, and learn where you can buy them across 15 supermarkets.

Pilgrims Choice

Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese

550g

What people say

56 reviews from 0 shop

“I think that it is about one of the best on the market and certainly has a better texture/flavour than Cathedral which I find greasy to cook with too”

“I love strong cheddar and this is the best I've tasted in a while”

Where to buy

VIEW PRODUCT

Pilgrims Choice

Extra Mature Grated Cheddar

180g

Where to buy

£1.75

£2.00

£2.55

VIEW PRODUCT

Pilgrims Choice

Mature Cheddar Cheese

350g

Where to buy

VIEW PRODUCT

Pilgrims Choice

Lighter Extra Mature Cheddar Cheese

350g

What people say

12 reviews from 1 shop

“Love this lighter version”

Where to buy

£4.25

VIEW PRODUCT

Pilgrims Choice

Extra Mature Lighter Big Pack

550g

Where to buy

£5.40

VIEW PRODUCT

Pilgrims Choice

Vintage Cheddar

300g

What people say

13 reviews from 1 shop

“I love this cheese”

“This is it”

Where to buy

£4.25

VIEW PRODUCT

Pilgrims Choice

Lighter Mature Cheddar Cheese

350g

What people say

22 reviews from 0 shop

“This is the best 'light' cheddar we've tasted”

Where to buy

VIEW PRODUCT

Pilgrims Choice

Sliced Extra Mature Cheddar

150g

What people say

17 reviews from 3 shops

“I love this cheese”

“I will definitely buy again”

Where to buy

£1.75

£2.00

£2.55