"I love black liquid eyeliner and through the years I've tried a great many varieties from high and lower end brands"

"This is my favorite eyeliner to this day since it draws a very beautiful and precise line and the color is a rich noir"

"This is not only overpriced but the liner claims to be waterproof to which is flakes off within hours of wearing"

"Love this liner!! Iceblack is a gorgeous shade - makes my green eyes stand out and complements my fair skin tone without being harsh"