"This is without doubt the worst cottage pie I have ever tasted - Charlie Bigham is trying to be too clever with what should be a simple classic"

"Very tasty and much better than most cheaper ready meals but I recommend that you make your own"

"This is lovely and tastes as close to homemade as you're going to get from a ready meal"

"I love the idea of these just because they aren't cooked in plastic and don't appear to have loads of E numbers and synthetic ingredients"